Forums Archive RPGMP3 Chatter Beyond the Mountains of Madness Beyond the Mountains of Madness Session 14

Viewing 15 posts - 16 through 30 (of 59 total)
  • Author
    Posts
  • #606612
    Keener
    • Posts : 4977
    • Drider
    woojitsu wrote:
    Face! Welcome back. Where have you been hiding?

    In the patrons area it really is just a nicer place. 😀

    #606613
    PrestoJeff
    • Posts : 447
    • Thri-kreen
    phillosmaster wrote:
    I’ve been trying to track down a copy of Day of the Beast for a reasonable price. It’s long been out of print, but I hear it rivals Masks in it’s expansiveness (without railroading the player).

    We’re playing, recording, and ‘casting it over at http://thegaminggrunts.com (including my “Keeper’s Diary”). It’s been called a bit of a “monster mash”, but the players seem to be enjoying it.

    #606614
    phillosmaster
    • Posts : 199
    • Orc

    I just subscribed. Thanks for the heads up.

    I see you’ve been playing for 33 sessions. About how far are you guys from completing the campaign?

    #606615
    PrestoJeff
    • Posts : 447
    • Thri-kreen
    phillosmaster wrote:
    I just subscribed. Thanks for the heads up.

    I see you’ve been playing for 33 sessions. About how far are you guys from completing the campaign?

    We’re pretty close to the end, I estimate the final session will be #37, #38, or maybe #39.

    #606616
    TheGlen
    • Posts : 296
    • Thri-kreen
    phillosmaster wrote:
    I didn’t realize that Daboingy was Charles’ last name. That caught me off guard when you were reading his character sheet. I think I laughed more than was appropriate.

    Technically it was Dubunya, it’s an ex-gf’s last name. Then again, I am known for horrifically bad hand writing and rather difficult to pronounce characters.

    #606617
    Alexandrian
    • Posts : 109
    • Orc

    Evening all,

    I thought I’d hassle you with my 10 pence worth. I thought that the adventure was fantastic. Although it was linear at times, the odd player diversions did make things very entertaining. This was the one adventure that I was completely absorbed by. I just couldn’t focus on anything else 😀

    All in all, thank you all for keeping me very entertained during my lonely nights at work 🙂

    #606618
    Anonymous
    • Posts : 1113
    • Owlbear

    Thanks all for doing this Cthulhu classic. Yes the adventure was linear but y’all (as I think they say in the South) made it a really entertaining ride! 😀

    As an aside, listening to this it’s just pleasantly amazing to see how the game affects the players and play… a lot of the players are also in D&D 4.0 I think but the style is soooooooooooooooo different there! 🙂 Roll on the next CoC! 8)

    #606619
    Bloodguard
    • Posts : 109
    • Orc

    I was very disappointed to hear Lindsay take the story down.

    It sounded as if she had a plan to end the game and went at it with vigor. I don’t sit at the table with you and wait for a chance to play or roll the dice, but for such an epic story line I was upset with the ending.

    The opportunity for roll/role play is in the hands of the players, the pace and direction is by the DM. You reversed the rolls and took the game into your hands and in doing so, the game collapsed. That was disappointing.

    You had gone thru 10 episodes, got into the real meat of the game and got bored with it. I couldn’t wait to see how the story would have gone on from the encounter with the machine. It was nerve wracking to hear the story taking shape and to hear Linds’ bring it down.

    Was this planned behind the scenes so that you didn’t have to play thru the next 4 to “?” chapters ?

    Did Glen step out of the event because he didn’t agree with the plan?

    Were you saddened, Hal when the group lost interest and wanted to give up right when the game got good?

    If they are unhappy with DnD 4-E ’cause of the fight-driven-system nature of it and they don’t like being ” railroaded ” by this CoC game, what is a good system?

    Is Rolemaster the best? Is there relevance to Warhammer or Exalted ?

    Do tell. . . .

    I loved the game! Sorry it wasn’t as easy to play as it was to listen to.

    Keep up the excellent work.

    #606620
    Lindsay
    • Posts : 2669
    • Succubus

    Glen didnt turn up to that session, and a few beforehand, hence Hal wanted the game to close, so we could start something different with a more regular schedule.

    I wont say anything else to defend myself, becasue everything I seem to say or do on this forum, or in a game is wrong atm.

    #606621
    MelkiorWhiteblade
    • Posts : 1180
    • Owlbear

    I didn’t see it that way at all. The last few sessions, especially the last two, seemed ripe for a TPK, which from what I understand of CoC is more normal than other systems.

    With sanity being so low, and most characters suffering from insanity of one type or another, it seemed like it was a no-win situation.

    In CoC, I get the feeling that the investigators can set the pace of the game. This scenario was an exception, as it was a “do this, do that” list of actions. Lake’s camp and the city were the only places where there were some options as to what to do.

    Considering what Lindsay had to work with, the only sane person in the group dealing with a bunch of people going insane, I think it made sense.

    #606622
    Keener
    • Posts : 4977
    • Drider

    Bloodguard I think you have missed some conversations and some intent through the game so I am sure that you will be given some slack with a slightly troll post, but I think the issue was not so much with COC directly and more with Beyond the Mountains of Madness. In the future though it may be a good thing to personally edit your post before get a little accusatory becuase remember the players and the GM are giving there free time to be recorded to entertain us. Thank you. 😀

    #606623
    Hal
    Admin
    • Posts : 7753
    • Treant

    I have to agree with the comments above. Call of Cthulhu is a fine fine game and we have run and played it successfully many times.

    The decision not to run the final chapters of the game were mine as I considered a pointless chase and more railroading to be a little unneccessary considering the state of the party at that point.

    I have no idea why you decided to target Lindsay specifically with these comments. It is things like this that really get her down. It may have seemed like Lindsay wanted to end the game in that session but to be honest the game was pretty much over by that point.

    BtMoM is a great story, but in my opinion it is a terrible game. It is far too linear and restrictive. There is a lot in there but the restrictions placed on the players are just too much to make things enjoyable. They do not feel free to act at all.

    I do have some plans to return to CoC in the future and give something else a shot, assuming the players let me. I have to say ‘trollish’ was a term that came to my mind when I read your post. There was really no need to specifically make attacks against a single player. It is offhand stuff like this that makes Lindsay wish she had never started doing this stuff in the first place.

    Play nice. No naming names.

    Cheers

    Hal :hal:

    #606624
    Thing
    Admin
    • Posts : 4512
    • Drider

    yeah, not sure what Bloodguard is trying to get to.

    I didn’t notice anything like what was described, in fact Lindsays role playins was some of my favorite moments in BtMoM.

    and even the closing note

    Quote:
    I loved the game! Sorry it wasn’t as easy to play as it was to listen to.

    Keep up the excellent work.

    seems a bit odd combined with the actual post.

    #606625
    BaronBytes
    • Posts : 17
    • Commoner

    I really liked listening to COC BtMoM, it made me go check Yog-Sothoth.com for more. and after listening to more CoC. I must agree entirely with Lindsay, at very few points the investigators really investigate, they are fed pages and pages of mountains description, boat sailing and survival camp preparation. When they can actually investigate they are under such time constraint and hard climate limit and monsters that there is not much they can do but follow the plot.

    In the end what happened was as much a TPK as can be(similar in a few ways to Ptolus’s end). Lindsay wasn’t playing her character. Batman was dead and Ape was insane. Glen’ character had been wanting to run away all of the two previous session (since the plane had been blown up if I remember)

    Nevertheless, Lindsay played my favorite character in it, “My Daddy own the globe” “click beeeeeeeeeep” and plenty other sound bites stay in my memories. The fact that people liked the game is a testament to the players not the module..

    Me I just want you to have fun, that’s what is making me listen to those audio games. So keep on playing what you want and have fun doing it. don’t mind us too much you’ll only spoil your fun.

    #606626
    Bloodguard
    • Posts : 109
    • Orc

    In NO way do I wish to upset Lindsay. I honestly believe it is her character roles that have made most of us fans of this site. I began listening to this site with . . . Labour of Love , I believe, then to World’s largest Dungeon, Hagemoth and the DnD stuff. I have LOVED all of the work !

    This is not an apology for my reasoning for my post but I am truly sorry to think that my criticism would upset Lindsay.

    As I listened to the story ( mind you, I really enjoyed the story telling aspect of it) it seemed that within the confines of this episode, it ended rather abruptly. That was disappointing to me as a listener. I liked these characters, they made me laugh, I was uneasy with them as they faced the events leading up to the plot & I wanted them to go crazy or paranoid or catatonic. . . All of these options seemed inevitable. When they started speaking of leaving for the ships and avoiding the story I was concerned that the option to leave was a consideration. I thought the idea of roll/role playing was to experiance the story, no matter what happened.

    I am SO VERY SORRY Hal and Lindsay to have been a part of this situation. I only offered the criticism because it surprised me to have the story end so abruptly.

    To Thing, I offered my comments only regarding this one session, I really do enjoy all of their work. I wish that it had not sounded so harsh.

    I accept the hate that will inevitably come my way on this. I suspect that most people will think it is rude in nature, I am sorry.

    Next time I will make my self more clear.

Viewing 15 posts - 16 through 30 (of 59 total)
  • The forum ‘Beyond the Mountains of Madness’ is closed to new topics and replies.