Forums Archive RPGMP3 Chatter Fashionista Gamers A new direction for the Fashionistas

Viewing 15 posts - 1 through 15 (of 188 total)
  • Author
    Posts
  • #557154
    MorkilRocks
    • Posts : 873
    • Gelatinous Cube

    Most of you know there has been a noticeable lack of the Fashionista Gamers’ audio. Hal, Lindsay and I have noticed it too. Due to various scheduling issues, we haven’t been able to get together as often as we’d like. Schedules can be worked around, but there is another issue the three of us have decided to tackle, head on.

    Playing the Carrion Crown story line has become increasingly frustrating for me. I find the plot points excessively dull and as I am sitting at the table, trying to enjoy the process, I find myself falling asleep listening to Hal read the back-story for Lindsay and I to understand. As such, playing with these story elements is no longer fun for me and I find myself losing interest in RPG’s all together.

    I though I was alone in this until I talked with Lindsay. She agrees that the story is excessive and bogged down in so many details, that she is finding it difficult to keep up with the elements too. So much so, that she has now parked her laptop at the table just to write notes during the game, which is not fun for her at all. Telling all of this to Hal revealed that he is not enjoying running the game because of the tone of the players.

    I get that the story is important, but at one point Hal is reading 3 pages of back-story, Lindsay is feverishly typing the information and I am sitting there twiddling my thumbs wondering when it will all end.

    Long story short, the three of us have decided that we are going to take a break from Carrion Crown. I suggested that we muddle through the rest of the Moon book, but Hal insists that this is a nice stopping point in the story. I am deferring to his judgment.

    Having experienced this much of RPG’s, I have come to the conclusion that the main element I dislike is the actual roleplay. I can’t divorce myself from my character; frankly it’s not that important to me that the character has a different personality or voice. This seems to be a major stumbling block for gaming.

    In an effort to save our gaming experience, Hal suggested an open-ended game of Rolemaster. He showed me some of the elements that are associated with it and there seems to be less of a defined story that leads you down a path and more of a system of small missions and tasks. I don’t know if this will instill a refreshed attitude about RPG’s in me, but I am willing to try.

    Lindsay, Hal and I are going to take some personal time off from recording anything this month and we will more than likely resume some sort of gaming schedule in January; however, there may or may not be a Christmas surprise soon.

    I would sincerely appreciate your thoughts and/or suggestions as to what we should do as a group to move this forward. If you just want to cuss me out, that will be fine too.

    Gilbert

    #633460
    Hal
    Admin
    • Posts : 7753
    • Treant

    Wow – that sounds pretty serious 🙂

    Let us not forget that we would have been taking a break anyway due to Lindsay having her surgery at the end of this week 🙂

    Also – I do not dislike Carrion Crown as an Adventure Path. It is well written and the story is sound. I am finding that with such a small group that there is some bogging down when it comes to the social aspect of things – they find it hard to keep track of all the NPCs and they are finding they are having to take HUGE amounts of notes where normally this burden would be spread over a number of different characters.

    If Rolemaster takes well we might end up with the system where we play one game of RM and one session of CC but if we start RM I would want to get it running for a while before stepping to 2 games in a day scenario 🙂

    Also – let me inject that I LOVE ROLEMASTER 🙂 (dances)

    Hal :hal:

    #633461
    Thing
    Admin
    • Posts : 4512
    • Drider

    Oooh, I do love me some Rolemaster!

    It can be tough tracking all the details on an investigative adventure, especially between sessions and a lot of that plot gets driven by skill and ability checks. Usually after an investigative game I find myself craving a good old fashioned hack and slash dungeon crawl.

    #633462
    MelkiorWhiteblade
    • Posts : 1180
    • Owlbear

    Hey, whatever works for you is what matters.

    If the story elements don’t jive for you, then it can be really hard to roleplay.

    Open ended games can be fun, and Hal is really good at running that sort of game. You can then define your motivation and run with in.

    Sounds exciting!

    #633463
    MonsterMike
    • Posts : 2
    • Commoner

    I’ve been listening to the Carrion Crown recordings (I’m up to the 4th session or so) and have to say I have really been enjoying them. However, I’m not surprised about the frustration you are experiencing.

    You have great chemistry as a group and obviously enjoy each other’s company as you game. Gilbert is a riot, Hal runs a fantastic game and has given me fresh insight for how to play a cleric, and Lindsey is simply awesome. But you may not be in the right type of game for the players.

    Given Gilbert’s love of shopping and Lindsey’s propensity to nick things that aren’t hers (in game, of course) you might want to consider a modern-day espionage system like Top Secret/SI or Mercenaries, Spies, and Private Eyes. Run a high class big heist type of story. Lots of gadgets to buy, spies have to be fabulously dressed at all times, and Teeka can continue to insist that she is not a thief. 😛

    #633464
    MorkilRocks
    • Posts : 873
    • Gelatinous Cube

    There were 31 sessions of Rolemaster that Hal ran with his other group. The last session was posted on January 25th, 2010.

    Do you all think it is too soon to start another Rolemaster campaign?

    If so, can you all think of another series/game that would work?

    MonsterMike wrote:
    Run a high class big heist type of story.

    I think I like the idea of a non-realistic game setting. Fighting dragons appeals to me more than robbing a bank. Nice suggestion though. I didn’t even know that type of game existed.

    G

    #633465
    Thing
    Admin
    • Posts : 4512
    • Drider
    MorkilRocks wrote:
    Do you all think it is too soon to start another Rolemaster campaign?

    If so, can you all think of another series/game that would work?

    I don’t think it is too soon, but if you are looking for non-realistic setting:

    Paranoia – Think Logans run with a comical twist. Your character is part of a series of clones and easily replacible.

    Gamma World – Like D&D, but in a post nuclear war mutant filled future

    #633466
    Lockhart
    • Posts : 1293
    • Owlbear

    A lengthier post coming after I’m done work, probably, but I don’t want Hal to forget he has like, three vouchers for a free game ran by me 😛

    #633467
    BigJackBrass
    • Posts : 4638
    • Drider
    MorkilRocks wrote:
    Do you all think it is too soon to start another Rolemaster campaign?

    If so, can you all think of another series/game that would work?

    Don’t forget that RoleMaster is not only a fantasy game, if you’re worried about that. I have their excellent pulp, viking and Greek supplements, for instance. Using a different fantasy setting than the previous game would also give it a very different flavour (although frankly I think that the difference in players will do that quite adequately anyway :D). For my money it’s an excellent choice, lots of useful mechanical crunch – and the ever-popular critical hit tables – but essentially straightforward as long as you have a GM who knows the ropes, as Hal certainly does.

    Still, maybe an historical setting might appeal. Greek, anyone? 😉

    #633468
    Thing
    Admin
    • Posts : 4512
    • Drider
    BigJackBrass wrote:

    Greek, anyone? 😉

    Gilbert? Your line, I believe.

    😉 😈

    #633469
    MorkilRocks
    • Posts : 873
    • Gelatinous Cube
    Thing wrote:
    BigJackBrass wrote:

    Greek, anyone? 😉

    Gilbert? Your line, I believe.

    😉 😈

    Thing, I am trying to have a serious conversation about gamin….. oh who am I kidding?

    THE LAST TIME I TRIED GREEK, I WAS PICKING LITTLE BLACK HAIRS OUT OF MY TEETH FOR A WEEK!

    There… happy?

    G 😀

    #633470
    Lindsay
    • Posts : 2669
    • Succubus

    Nice posting, Gilbert..

    Nothing for me to add except a little “Yay, Rolemaster” 🙂

    #633471
    Helaman
    • Posts : 52
    • Bullywug

    Firstly – Best wishes for Lindsay.

    Secondly – Thanks for all the entertainment

    Third – I’ll miss you 🙁

    Fourth – Rolemaster? AYKM? That is NOT an easy system – I’ve played it (and Spacemaster), and loved it but its a lot of work in character generation and leveling. That said? Crits for the WIN!

    I’m looking forward to seeing you back and recording but its one of those things – you have to enjoy it. I personally think CC is the mutts nuts, bees knees and other wonderful bits of assorted animals but I also love story, plot and investigation above the action of combat.

    Edit: It also sounds like you need a third player. I don’t think you are rolling in ‘excess’ gamers atm but the addition would help.

    Anyways – thanks again. I’ll hit the forums periodically to check on you all.

    #633472
    Caralad
    • Posts : 4
    • Commoner

    As much as I personally love the setting for Carrion Crown (Horror settings have always been a personal favourite of mine) I can easily hear that you’re not enjoying it fully. I think trying another game after a break could be a good thing for you, and I can easily imagine gilbert falling in love with the crit system in Rolemaster.

    #633473
    LightPagoda
    • Posts : 512
    • Gelatinous Cube

    ” I have come to the conclusion that the main element I dislike is the actual roleplay. I can’t divorce myself from my character; frankly it’s not that important to me that the character has a different personality or voice. ” I dont think think the inability to seperate player from character is all that unusual for new players. I am listening to the Gaming Grunts podcast and its fairly clear in their debut Call of Cthulu game that most of the players were having that issue, one in particular wasnt even trying. They still seemed to have fun and its been mostly enjoyable listening so far. I’ve got two young guys in my non-recording group right now that are pretty much paper cutout dnd adventurers, even to the point of living in the inn and getting drunk whenever they have off time. They are just into the game more for the combat then characters and story, but they still have enough fun to keep coming back. The key is just to find what you like and find a setting and system that provides that. I would suggest looking at movies/books that you think would be fun to play through as a group and let Hal or the forums suggest systems/settings that might match the elements you found interesting. I am running Ootak through a savage worlds game based on the “Monster Hunter International” book series which is more combat, good vs evil and fantastic element oriented to have a break from out Traveller campaign which was scifi and where the characters were at best a dark grey morally. Maybe you want to listen to a session or two from different greoups to get a broader idea of what is possible.

Viewing 15 posts - 1 through 15 (of 188 total)
  • The forum ‘Fashionista Gamers’ is closed to new topics and replies.